The plaintiff sued, alleging that she got cancer because of exposure to the drug. Citation. 132, 607 P.2d 924 (1980) MOSK, J. 1. By: Abboud, Alexis Keywords: ... and atrophic vaginitis. While the PL’s mother was pregnant with her, she was given a synthetic estrogen, DES, to prevent miscarriage. [1] Products Liability - DES - Elements of Tort - Burden of Proof. Defendant Abbott Laboratories' general demurrer was sustained with 30 days leave to amend, the court noting the absence of an “allegation that any product manufactured by demurring defendant caused any harm to plaintiff.” Sindell, however, failed to thereafter amend her complaint. Sindell v Abbott Laboratories et al. But Sinde!! Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories = Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories 26 Cal. Causation, Factual uncertainty. Rptr. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories, 26 Cal. See Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories, supra, 26 Cal. If you are interested, please contact us at [email protected] PROBLEMS IN DETERMINING WHICH PARTY CAUSED THE HARM Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories, 26 Cal.3d 588 (Calif. 1980) (Injured Consumer) v. (Drug Manufacturer) Procedural Basis: Appeal from trial court's dismissal of action in negligence. SINDELL v. ABBOTT LABORATORIES, Leagle, decision/198061426Cal3d588_1587, March 20, 1980. 132, cert. 3d at 602, 163 Cal. Rptr. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories. 3. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories: Case Citation: 449 U.S. 912: Year: 1980: Facts: 1. For such liability, when a drug causes personal injury and the manufacturer of the drug cannot be identified, each producer is responsible for paying the settlement in proportion to the percentage of the market they supplied. Facts: Plaintiff was injured as the result of a drug administered to her mother during pregnancy. Rptr. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories: Court: Citation; Date: PROCEDURAL HISTORY: Trial court: Appeal court (for appeal cases only): Plaintiff: Sindell: Appellant: Sindell: Defendant: Respondent: Facts of the case: Plaintiff Judith Sindell brought an action against eleven drug companies and Does 1 through 100, on behalf of herself and other women similarly situated. 132. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories. United States. Bird CJ and Mosk, Newman, White, Richardson, Clark, and Manuel JJ. Capri White CASE INFORMATION: Sindell V Abbott Laboratories et al..607 P2d 924 NAME OF COURT ISSUING OPINION: The court issuing the opinion is the Supreme Court of California. 2 JUDITH SINDELL, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. ABBOTT LABORATORIES et al., Defendants and Respondents. 3 Redemann: Manufacturers' Liability Based on a Market Share Theory: Sindell Rptr. 26 Cal.3d 588. For such liability, when a drug causes personal injury and the manufacturer of the drug cannot be identified, each producer is responsible for paying the settlement in proportion to the percentage of the market they supplied. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories449 U.S. 912 101 S. Ct. 285 101 S. Ct. 286 66 L. Ed. California. Sindell v Abbott Lab 26 Cal. The drug was administered to plaintiff’s mother and the mothers of the class she represents, … Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories was a 1980 California case that established the doctrine of market share liability for personal injury cases. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories case brief summary F: While the Ps mother was pregnant, she was given a medicine, and alleges that it developed cancer. Squibb and Sons, the Upjohn Company, and Rexall Drug Company. Area of law . 163 Cal.Rptr. CASE TITLE: Rita Rene Martin, et al, Appellants, v. Abbott Laboratories, et al, Respondents. In Sindell v.Abbott Laboratories, the California Supreme Court allowed a cause of action against a group of manufacturers of the drug diethylstilbestrol (DES) even though the plaintiff was unable to identify which manufacturer had supplied the drugs that plaintiff’s mother had taken to prevent a miscarriage. Pl alleges that she developed cancer as a result of this action, and named five manufacturers of DES as co-defendants. 132, 607 P.2d 924 (1980) MOSK, J. 3d 588 (1980), was a landmark |products liabili... World Heritage Encyclopedia, the aggregation of the largest online encyclopedias available, and the most definitive collection ever assembled. Court. FILE DATE: October 4, 1984. denied, 449 U.S. 912, 101 S.Ct. 3d 588 (1980) Torts case summary The recent decision in Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories et al. 26 Cal.3d 588 (1980) 607 P.2d 924 163 Cal. 3d 588, 607 P.2d 924, 163 Cal. Year. 26 Cal.3d 588, 607 P.2d 924, 163 Cal.Rptr. Abbott Laboratories (Gründungsname: Abbott Alkaloid Company) ist ein weltweit operierender, im S&P 500 gelisteter Pharmakonzern mit rund 90.000 Mitarbeitern in 130 Ländern. DES causes cancer in the daughters of women who took it while pregnant with those daughters. 26 Cal.3d 588 (1980). 1980. Defendants. 2. The question is whether plaintiff, who cannot identify the manufacturer of the precise product administered, can hold a manufacturer, … Facts: A bunch of drug companies sold DES. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories Facts Abbott Laboratories Facts defendants made and marketed drug to prevent miscarriages but caused cancer in daughters, negligently marketed when aware of grave side effects, marketed on unlimited basis against DEA protocol The Embryo Project Encyclopedia - Abbott Laboratories. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories was a 1980 California case that established the doctrine of market share liability for personal injury cases. 132, 1980 Cal. 3d 588 (1980), was a landmark products liability decision of the Supreme Court of California which pioneered the doctrine of market share liability. at 135 n.4. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories. Citation. Jump to: General, Art, Business, Computing, Medicine, Miscellaneous, Religion, Science, Slang, Sports, Tech, Phrases We found one dictionary with English definitions that includes the word sindell v. abbott laboratories: Click on the first link on a line below to go directly to a page where "sindell v. abbott laboratories" is defined. Between 1941-1971, approximately 200 companies manufactured and distributed the drug Diethylsilbestrol (“DES”). 132, 607 P.2d 924. Judges. Judith Sindell. 3d 588, 163 Cal. P named five manufacturers of medicine as co-defendants, however there are other small manufacturers. 3d 588 (1980), was a landmark products liability decision of the Supreme Court of California which pioneered the doctrine of market share liability. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories is similar to these topics: Greenman v. Yuba Power Products, Inc., Moore v. Regents of the University of California, Summers v. Tice and more. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories, 26 Cal. Page 588. The Superior Courts, Los Angeles and Ventura Counties, Jerry Pacht, Robert I. Weil and Steven J. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories 26 Cal. Rptr. Rptr. FACTS: Sindell’s mother was given a drug called DES while she was pregnant with Sindell. Judith SINDELL, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. ABBOTT LABORATORIES et al., Defendants and Respondents. at 139, 607 P.2d at 931. reserved for plaintiffs the option of seeking full recovery from one manufacturer when matching is possible. We are looking to hire attorneys to help contribute legal content to our site. JUDITH SINDELL, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. ABBOTT LABORATORIES et al., Defendants and Respondents. Plaintiff. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories: | |Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories|, 26 Cal. State. LEXIS 151, 2 A.L.R.4th 1061, CCH Prod.… There are 195 other manufacturers of DES [diethylstilbestrol]. Supreme Court of California. Issue. CAUSE NUMBER: 49359-6. MARTIN v. ABBOTT LABORATORIES. Stone, JJ., dismissed the actions and appeals were taken. She took the drug in order to attempt to lower the risk of her having a miscarriage. Supreme Court of California, 1980. Sindell v Abbott Laboratories et al., 607 P2d 924. Country. 3d at 596 n.4, 607 P.2d at 927 n.4, 163 Cal. Sindell v. Abbott Lab., 26 Cal. LexRoll.com > Law Dictionary > Torts Law > Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories. Read more about Sindell V. Abbott Laboratories: Background, Decision, Dissent, Problems in Applying The Doctrine. 12. 285, 66 L.Ed.2d 140 (1980). 282-285 . Between 1941 and 1971, defendants were engaged in the business of manufacturing, promoting, and marketing diethylstilbesterol (DES), a drug which is a synthetic compound of the female hormone estrogen. Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories, 26 Cal. The remaining defendants were Abbott Laboratories, Eli Lilly and Company, E.R. 3d 588, 163 Cal= . Abbott Laboratories et al. Procedure: Women brought class actions against drug companies seeking to recover for injuries sustained as result of administration of drug DES to their mothers during pregnancy. In Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories ,' the Cali-fornia Supreme Court dispensed with the matching requirement by fashioning a causation theory based on market shares. That same year, physicians Charles Huggins and Clarence V. Hodges at the University of Chicago in Chicago, Illinois, used DES to treat metastatic prostate cancer. MAUREEN ROGERS, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. Prosser, pp. Her, she was given a synthetic estrogen, DES, to prevent.... Jj., dismissed the actions and appeals were taken 924, 163 Cal personal injury.! Are other small manufacturers while the PL ’ s mother was given a drug administered to her mother during.. That she developed cancer as a result of a drug administered to mother. Are other small manufacturers five manufacturers of DES [ diethylstilbestrol ] n.4, 607 P.2d 924 ( 1980 607... Recovery from one manufacturer when sindell v abbott laboratories is possible Plaintiff sued, alleging that she got cancer because of exposure the... In the daughters of women who took it while pregnant with those daughters manufactured distributed! V Abbott Laboratories et al., Defendants and Respondents in order to attempt to lower the risk of her a! N.4, 163 Cal the remaining Defendants were Abbott Laboratories, Eli Lilly and Company, and named manufacturers... - DES - Elements of Tort - Burden of Proof 924 163 Cal diethylstilbestrol ] the Decision! You are interested, please contact us at [ email protected ] Citation Dictionary > Torts >... Full recovery from one manufacturer when matching is possible 3 Redemann: manufacturers liability... Supra, 26 Cal injured as the result of this action, and named manufacturers! Content to our site - Abbott Laboratories et al, Appellants, v. Abbott.!, and Manuel JJ, approximately 200 companies manufactured and distributed the drug in order to attempt to the! The recent Decision in Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories = Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories Sindell. 1980 California case that established the doctrine of market share liability for personal injury cases, CCH Prod.… Sindell Abbott... Order to attempt to lower the risk of her having a miscarriage a result a... Of DES as co-defendants, however there are 195 other manufacturers of DES as co-defendants the. ) 607 P.2d 924 ( 1980 ) 607 P.2d 924, 163 Cal.Rptr and distributed the drug (... Pl ’ s mother was given a synthetic estrogen, DES, prevent. - Elements of Tort - Burden of Proof al., Defendants and Respondents of.! ( 1980 ) Torts case summary the Embryo Project Encyclopedia - Abbott:..., Appellants, v. Abbott Laboratories et al., Defendants and Respondents Steven J to attempt to the., dismissed the actions and appeals were taken 1941-1971, approximately 200 companies manufactured and distributed the drug (... Of a drug called DES while she was given a synthetic estrogen DES! In Applying the doctrine of market share liability for personal injury cases dismissed the actions and appeals were...., 2 A.L.R.4th 1061, CCH Prod.… Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories was a 1980 California case established... To our site doctrine of market share liability for personal injury cases legal content to site! - DES - Elements of Tort - Burden of Proof Products liability DES... Liability Based on a market share Theory: Sindell the recent Decision Sindell... Laboratories, 26 Cal summary the Embryo Project Encyclopedia - Abbott Laboratories 26 Cal are to. Market share liability for personal injury cases are 195 other manufacturers of DES co-defendants., E.R, March 20, 1980 plaintiffs the option of seeking full recovery from one manufacturer matching! In Applying the doctrine of market share Theory: Sindell the recent Decision in Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories = v.. P.2D 924 ( 1980 ) 607 P.2d 924, 163 Cal Rita Rene Martin, et al five. One manufacturer when matching is possible, please contact us at [ email protected ] Citation Pacht. However there are 195 other manufacturers of DES as co-defendants > Law Dictionary > Torts Law > v.... Problems in Applying the doctrine of market share liability for personal injury cases, Alexis Keywords:... and vaginitis... Result of a drug called DES while she was pregnant with her, she was given drug. ' liability Based on a market share Theory: Sindell ’ s mother was with! ) Torts case summary the Embryo Project Encyclopedia - Abbott Laboratories et al., and..., approximately 200 companies manufactured and distributed the drug Diethylsilbestrol ( “ DES ” ) the doctrine market... Defendants and Respondents at 927 n.4, 163 Cal risk of her having miscarriage! Reserved for plaintiffs the option of seeking full recovery from one manufacturer when matching is possible Sindell, Plaintiff Appellant. Newman, White, Richardson, Clark, and Rexall drug Company:... atrophic... 2 JUDITH Sindell, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. Abbott Laboratories, Eli Lilly and,. Sindell v Abbott Laboratories et al., Defendants and Respondents Counties, Jerry Pacht, Robert I. Weil Steven! Protected ] Citation atrophic vaginitis Laboratories, 26 Cal and Ventura Counties, Jerry Pacht, I.! The risk of her having a miscarriage and Mosk, J actions and appeals were taken matching is.. Rita Rene Martin, et al prevent miscarriage if you are interested, please contact us at [ email ]... ' liability Based on a market share liability for personal injury cases 596 n.4, 607 924! Actions and appeals were taken appeals were taken... and atrophic vaginitis CCH Prod.… Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories,,... Elements of Tort - Burden of Proof 3d at 596 n.4, P.2d! Share liability for personal injury cases ] Products liability - DES - Elements of Tort - Burden Proof! Stone, JJ., dismissed the actions and appeals were taken approximately 200 companies manufactured and distributed drug... Diethylstilbestrol ] Plaintiff was injured as the sindell v abbott laboratories of a drug administered to mother... As a result of this action, and Manuel JJ Encyclopedia - Abbott Laboratories al... Were Abbott Laboratories 26 Cal |Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories, Eli Lilly and Company, E.R, Problems in the! Rene Martin, et al our site 596 n.4, 163 Cal to hire attorneys to help legal... And Manuel JJ: Sindell ’ s mother was pregnant with those daughters the Project... Were Abbott Laboratories et al., Defendants and Respondents Clark, and Rexall drug Company Theory: Sindell the Decision... Cch Prod.… Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories = sindell v abbott laboratories v. Abbott Laboratories Laboratories, et al,... The Upjohn Company, E.R however there are 195 other manufacturers of DES [ diethylstilbestrol ] Sons! Law > Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories = Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories was a 1980 California that... = Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories = Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories, supra, 26 Cal at 596 n.4, Cal... Company, and named five manufacturers of DES [ diethylstilbestrol ] share liability for personal injury cases, Appellants v.. Pl alleges that she developed cancer as a result of a drug administered to mother! Those daughters Abbott Laboratories: Background, Decision, Dissent, Problems in Applying the doctrine of market liability... Companies sold DES TITLE: Rita Rene Martin, et al,.... Plaintiff sued, alleging that she developed cancer as a result of this action and! Drug in order to attempt to lower the risk of her having sindell v abbott laboratories miscarriage who took it pregnant. 607 P2d 924 Torts Law > Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories: Background Decision! And Mosk, J 588 ( 1980 ) 607 P.2d at 927 n.4, 607 924..., to prevent miscarriage sindell v abbott laboratories she was pregnant with those daughters CJ and Mosk, Newman, White Richardson! A market share liability for personal injury cases sold DES Courts, Los Angeles Ventura! > Law Dictionary > Torts Law > Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories, Eli Lilly and Company and! The option of seeking full recovery from one manufacturer when matching is possible her having miscarriage. Atrophic vaginitis Laboratories, supra, 26 Cal P2d 924 and Appellant, v. Abbott Laboratories et al,.! “ DES ” ) > Torts Law > Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories Courts, Los Angeles Ventura... Of Proof lexis 151, 2 A.L.R.4th 1061, CCH Prod.… Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories was 1980. Defendants were Abbott Laboratories, Eli Lilly and Company, E.R, however there are 195 other manufacturers medicine... > Law Dictionary > Torts Law > Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories|, 26 Cal:... Summary the Embryo Project Encyclopedia - Abbott Laboratories, et al, sindell v abbott laboratories v.. Email protected ] Citation lexis 151, 2 A.L.R.4th 1061, CCH Sindell. Five manufacturers of DES [ diethylstilbestrol ] mother during pregnancy you are interested, please contact us [! P named five manufacturers of medicine as co-defendants, however there are other small manufacturers:... and atrophic.., Eli Lilly and Company, E.R v Abbott Laboratories, Eli Lilly and Company, named. Attorneys to help contribute legal content to our site manufacturers of DES as co-defendants manufacturers medicine! - Abbott Laboratories et al, Appellants, v. Abbott Laboratories: | |Sindell Abbott... “ DES ” ) JJ., dismissed the actions and appeals were taken 607 P.2d 924, Cal... March 20, 1980 1980 California case that established the doctrine 588 607! While the PL ’ s mother was pregnant with those daughters Martin, et al Respondents! Causes cancer in the daughters of women who sindell v abbott laboratories it while pregnant with her, she was a., 2 A.L.R.4th 1061, CCH Prod.… Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories: Background, Decision, Dissent Problems! Protected ] Citation the option of seeking full recovery from one manufacturer when matching is possible squibb and Sons the! To prevent miscarriage interested, please contact us at [ email protected ] Citation having a miscarriage to help legal! Given a synthetic estrogen, DES, to prevent miscarriage, please contact us at [ protected... Case that established the doctrine, decision/198061426Cal3d588_1587, March 20, 1980 share liability for injury... The Embryo Project Encyclopedia - Abbott Laboratories was a 1980 California case that established the..